| Randy Wesig | 31 | Red Line, Three-peat, Ho Ho ... |
| True Houser | 30 | Going for Gold, Missed a Spot, Strength ... |
| Dana Studebaker | 25 | Weiner, Red Line, Deja Vu ... |
| Ben Marsh | 22 | Game Room, Red Line, Deja Vu ... |
| Dave Vanderburgh | 20 | Daily Double, Arcade, Billionaire Club ... |
| Chris Lowe | 19 | Weiner, Missed a Spot, Yo-Yo ... |
| Jeff Hecht | 18 | Yo-Yo, Game Room, Weiner ... |
| Joshua Simala | 17 | Red Line Mania, Cherry Picker, Missed a Spot ... |
| Jon Gray | 17 | Finish Line, Missed a Spot, Weiner ... |
| David Jones | 17 | Did Your Time, Beating the Odds, Cherry Picker ... |
| Dalva Ireland | 16 | Red Line, Crushing Victory, Weiner ... |
| Mark Knapke | 15 | Lollipop, Deja Vu, Weiner ... |
| Jon Vollmer | 15 | Crushing Victory, Finish Line, Lollipop ... |
| Chad Marsh | 14 | Finish Line, Weiner, Best in Show ... |
| Tom Bentley | 14 | Hell Yes, Red Line, Crushing Victory ... |
| Tony Becker | 14 | Slick Flipper, Red Line, Best in Show ... |
| Chaise Wilson | 14 | Crushing Victory, Game Room, Gets Around ... |
| Luke Becker | 13 | Best in Show, Weiner, Head of the Class ... |
| Ian Kinner | 11 | Best in Show, Going for Gold, Missed a Spot ... |
| Brittney Pritchett | 10 | Crushing Victory, Missed a Spot, Best in Show ... |
| Jessica Valle | 3 | Weiner, Crushing Victory, Best in Show |
| Kayce Stewart | 2 | Red Line, Snake Eyeses |
| Vern Staats | 2 | Red Line, Clone |
| Bob Gross | 1 | Lollipop |
| Bob Ellis | 1 | Lollipop |